Residential portable v standby generator side-by-side

Portable Generators vs. Permanent Standby Generators: What’s Right for Your Home?

When it comes to keeping your home powered during an outage, there are two primary options: a portable generator or a permanent standby generator. Each option has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the right choice depends on your specific needs, budget, and lifestyle. Below, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both portable and standby generators to help you make an informed decision.

Portable Generators

Portable generators are a popular choice for many homeowners due to their affordability and flexibility. These generators are typically gas-powered and can be moved from place to place as needed.

Pros of Portable Generators

1. Affordability: Portable generators are generally less expensive upfront compared to standby generators. This makes them a more accessible option for many homeowners.
2. Flexibility: Because they are portable, these generators can be used in multiple locations, whether it’s at home, a job site, or a camping trip. Their versatility is a significant advantage.
3. No Installation Required: Portable generators do not require professional installation. They are typically plug-and-play, making them easy to set up and use.
4. Compact Size: These generators are generally smaller and can be stored in a garage or shed when not in use, taking up minimal space. Corinne Rodriguez, Duthie Power Services Sales Manager, adds, “A portable generator can help you get by with the bare minimum of electricity in an emergency. It’s not capable of running appliances that require a lot of energy, like air-conditioning units, but it will keep your lights on.”

Cons of Portable Generators

1. Manual Operation: Portable generators require manual setup and operation, including refueling and starting the unit during an outage. This might not be ideal in severe weather conditions or for those who are less physically able.
2. Limited Power Output: While portable generators can power essential appliances, they usually don’t have the capacity to run an entire house. You may need to be selective about which appliances or systems to keep running during an outage.
3. Noise: Portable generators can be quite loud, which may be a nuisance to you and your neighbors, especially during nighttime use.
4. Fuel Storage: These generators typically run on gasoline, which means you’ll need to store fuel safely and have enough on hand for extended outages.
5. Safety Concerns: Improper use of portable generators can lead to safety risks, such as carbon monoxide poisoning if used indoors or too close to the house.

Permanent Standby Generators

Permanent standby generators are larger, more powerful units that are permanently installed outside your home. They automatically kick in when there’s a power outage and are typically connected to your home’s natural gas or propane supply.

Pros of Standby Generators

1. Automatic Operation: Standby generators turn on automatically during a power outage, ensuring your home remains powered without any manual intervention. This is a significant advantage during storms or when you’re away from home.
2. Higher Power Capacity: These generators can power your entire home, including HVAC systems, lights, appliances, and more, providing seamless comfort and functionality during an outage.
3. Continuous Fuel Supply: Since standby generators are connected to a natural gas or propane line, you don’t need to worry about refueling, even during extended outages.
4. Quiet Operation: Standby generators are generally quieter than portable ones. As Mike Goodman, Duthie Power Sales Engineer, describes it, “There are no 100% quiet generators; they just don’t exist. But in an emergency, the sound of that generator kicking on will be the envy of your neighbors.”
5. Long-Term Investment: While more expensive upfront, a standby generator can add value to your home and provide peace of mind, especially in areas prone to frequent power outages.

Cons of Standby Generators

1. Cost: Standby generators are significantly more expensive than portable generators, both in terms of the unit itself and the installation costs. This can be a barrier for some homeowners.
2. Installation Requirements: Professional installation is required, including electrical work and possibly gas line connections. This adds to the overall cost and complexity.
3. Space Requirements: These units are larger and require a dedicated outdoor space for installation, which might not be feasible for all homeowners. Mike Goodman adds, “In order to get a permit approved, most jurisdictions require your generator has five feet of clearance from your property line and if located near your home, five feet of clearance from any windows or doors.”
4. Maintenance: While generally low-maintenance, standby generators require regular exercising and maintenance, just like any other permanent generator, to ensure they’re ready to operate when needed.
5. Permanent Fixture: Unlike portable generators, standby generators are a permanent fixture, meaning you can’t move them or take them with you if you relocate.

Which Is Right for You?

The decision between a portable and a standby generator comes down to your specific needs, budget, and how often you expect to use the generator. If you need a cost-effective, flexible solution for occasional power outages, a portable generator may be the best choice. Also, if you’re limited on space around your property, a portable may be your only choice. However, if you’re looking for a reliable, automatic system that can power your entire home, a standby generator is the way to go.

Ultimately, both types of generators can provide essential power during an outage, but understanding the pros and cons of each will help you choose the one that best suits your home and lifestyle.

The Generator Experts at Duthie Power Services specialize in commercial and industrial generator installations, but we are happy to help you explore your options and get you the backup system you need. Give us a call at 800-899-3931 or request a quote so we can connect you a qualified professional.